First off, it is a 2005 F4i with almost 9,000 miles on the clock. I have had her for only a couple months, but I am no stranger to bikes. This is my 6th bike and I have been riding for over 20 years in the dirt and 7 years on the street.

I have put about 3,000 miles on her since I got her and she is due for an oil change this weekend. Other than that, she is mint! (Well I'll have to do the CCT soon, starting to hear a little buzz around 5k only when the bike is cold.)

So the problem is when I am up shifting into 5th or 6th gear, it sometimes misses the shift and grinds really bad. I have to pop it up again for it to get into gear. It seems to do it more when at low RPMs compared to high RPMs. It also only does it when I have the clutch engaged, if I up shift without using the clutch, she pops right into gear with no issues. When I shift into 2nd, 3rd or 4th it pops right into gear with no issues and I can hear it pop and feel it in my foot. When I up shift into 5th and/or 6th it does not "pop", I can't hear it go into gear or feel it in my foot, even when it shifts correctly. The issue is totally random and I can't seem to re-create it, just happens whenever.

I originally thought it could be a clutch issue, but after speaking with a mechanic he said if it was a clutch it would effect all gears, not just 5th and 6th. I guess this makes sense, but I'm no mechanic... He also said that it might be the cheap oil they used at the dealer since it has been getting worse as I put on more miles, but it should effect all gears as well.

Either way, they want a butt load of money to open up the trans and take a look around. Does anyone have any ideas before I fork over the cash? I am of course going to wait till after I do the oil change to have the mechanic look, but I want to get some other opinions.

Thanks in advance!

 

hopefully the oil change will do it

 

Does it do it just during upshifts or downshifts as well?

 

Only up shifting... but you can up shift without the clutch with no issues, pops right into 5th and/or 6th.

 

I have to agree with the dealer that its not a clutch issue because it does make sense that it would do it in all gears then. I also don't know if it would be bad gears cause I would think it would grid on downshifts too. I do have a feeling that you won't know the cause until you crack open the case.